My Pet Carnivore Reviews
My Pet Carnivore has an overall rating of 3.3 based on 36 reviews. Customer feedback on My Pet Carnivore is mixed: My Pet Carnivore reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality raw pet food, excellent customer service, convenient subscription options, and diverse product selection, which strongly appeal to pet owners seeking raw food diets for their pets. However, My Pet Carnivore is often criticized for its higher price point, limited shipping options, occasional delivery delays, and lack of variety in certain products.
36 reviews
5 Stars
6
4 Stars
8
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
8
1 Star
3
How would you rate My Pet Carnivore?
All My Pet Carnivore Reviews (36)
GARCIA
May 19, 2026
"Packed really well"
My order from mypetcarnivore.com showed up in really good shape. Everything was still cold, cold enough that I wasn’t worried at all, and all the bags were sealed with no leaks or busted spots. The box itself was sturdy too, which I appreciate because deliveries can get tossed around sometimes. Overall, happy with how it arrived.
0
Reply
Connie-sprayberry
May 15, 2026
"Super Transparent"
They actually show where everything comes from, which I really appreciate. Refreshing. It just makes the whole experience feel more honest and trustworthy.
0
Reply
norman_Paul93
May 08, 2026
"Communication Was Actually Decent"
They kept me posted throughout the process, which was nice for a change. Communication was good, and I didn’t have to chase them down too much, so that was appreciated.
0
Reply
LIZOTTE
May 05, 2026
"Pretty Reliable"
They usually have what I need, so it’s kinda become one of my go-to spots
0
Reply
hello_ollie546
April 22, 2026
"Showed up quick and still cold"
My order came faster than I thought it was going to, which was nice because it was frozen stuff and I was kind of watching for that. The box was still cold when it got here and everything seemed packed fine. The only thing was the tracking didn’t really update much at the beginning, so that was a little not helpful, but overall the shipping was good
0
Reply
joseph_Siddique03
April 16, 2026
"Pretty "smooth" shopping experience"
The website was really easy to get around, and I found what I needed quickly. Checkout was "no hassle" at all, which I always appreciate. Overall, it was a smooth experience.
0
Reply
CANNADAY
April 13, 2026
"Feels like a more thoughtful choice for my dog"
I’ve been ordering from My Pet Carnivore for a while now, and I really appreciate that the organ mix feels balanced instead of just being a bunch of liver thrown in. That matters to me because if I’m choosing to feed raw, I feel like I should be doing it responsibly and not just guessing. My dog has been doing well on it, and his stools are normal, which is usually my sign that it isn’t too rich or overdone. The packaging has always been fine too. Nothing fancy, just solid, honest food that works for us.
0
Reply
cherylnguyen4029
April 12, 2026
"Decent food, if you enjoy spending that much"
I tried mypetcarnivore.com for my dog, and to be fair, the food seemed fine. My dog ate it without any drama, so I guess that part was a win. But once the product cost and shipping were added together, the total got ridiculous for what felt like a regular monthly order. Maybe it makes sense if you have a budget where price is just a cute little detail, but for me, it was hard to justify. Not bad food, just way too expensive for me to buy again.
0
Reply
ryan-Sawyer
April 08, 2026
"A little pricey for me"
I really wanted to like ordering from here, but it just feels a bit expensive for what you end up getting. Shipping kind of pushes it even higher, so it’s hard to make it feel worth it. The quality seems fine overall, but for my budget right now, I can’t really justify it.
0
Reply
FLOYD
March 03, 2026
"Local pickup is a hassle again"
Once again, the local pickup option ended up being more annoying than helpful. It’s not really that close, so it just feels like another extra errand instead of a convenient pickup.
0
Reply
christina1998
February 02, 2026
"My Dog Did Well With It"
My dog handled the bone content really well, which was a big relief since I’m always a little cautious with that kind of thing. I do wish the product description had been a bit clearer about the bone content upfront, just so I knew exactly what to expect. That said, my dog had no issues at all and seemed totally fine with it, so overall I’m happy with how it went.
0
Reply
LouieHill_20
January 30, 2026
"Dogs stomach is finally doing better"
I switched my dog over to this and his stomach has been doing a lot better. His stools are firmer now and he doesnt seem as itchy as before, which is a big relief. Shipping was mostly fine too, though I do wish the packing was a little easier to open.
0
Reply
JudithDoggett
January 27, 2026
"good portions"
i was happy with the portion sizes. everything felt like a solid amount for the price, and i definitely didn’t leave hungry
0
Reply
alana.Diamond
January 26, 2026
"My dog wasn’t impressed"
I really wanted this to work, but my dog just wasn’t into it. He’d sniff it, take a couple bites, and then walk away like I’d served him something offensive. I even went through the extra hassle of mixing it with his regular food and warming it up, which felt like more work than feeding him should be, and he still wasn’t interested. Maybe other pets will like the taste, but for us it was definitely a miss
0
Reply
LeonardWinkler
January 22, 2026
"My frozen order arrived in a bit of a meltdown"
I was really looking forward to this order, but when it arrived, it was kind of a disaster scene. It wasn’t fully frozen, a few packs were soft, and some were even leaking a little. I know shipping frozen items can be tricky, but for the price, I expected it to hold up much better. Disappointing experience overall...
0
Reply
evan_Wright77
January 19, 2026
"Finally a Raw Food That’s Been Easy on My Dog’s Stomach"
My dog has a really sensitive stomach, so I was nervous about trying raw food again. So far with My Pet Carnivore, he’s been doing a lot better than I expected. No loose stools, no weird gas, and he’s not acting uncomfortable after meals like he used to, which is a huge relief. The only thing is that I definitely had to take it slow when switching him over, so it wasn’t exactly a quick transition. But ordering was simple, everything arrived packed well, and I’m mostly just happy that his digestion seems calm for once.
0
Reply
paulawoodworth3224
January 16, 2026
"Decent for Raw Feeding, But Not Perfect"
I use this for raw feeding my dog, and overall it works okay for what I expected. Some items have been great, but others are kind of hit or miss, so it really depends on what you get. I was hoping for a little more consistency, especially since the prices can feel a bit high at times.
0
Reply
Robert-hazen
January 11, 2026
"Still Waiting, Somehow"
I reached out expecting the issue to actually get fixed, but surprise, it’s still not resolved. Always fun when something simple turns into a whole ongoing project.
0
Reply
holley_Card76
January 01, 2026
"Not sure what happened with my order"
I ordered the chicken and rabbit, but when I opened the box it was mostly turkey instead. At first I thought maybe I had misread my order or clicked the wrong thing, so I went back and checked everything. They did fix part of the issue, but I still felt like I had to double-check every item in the box just to make sure I wasn’t missing something
0
Reply
jamesgaleano8595
December 28, 2025
"Return was okay, but am I missing something?"
I had to return part of my order and it was a bit of a mixed experience. Customer service did get back to me and the refund eventually came through, so that part was fine. But it took longer than I expected, and I had to follow up once to get things moving. Am I missing something, or could this process just be a little smoother? Not terrible, but definitely room for improvement
0
Reply
Have a question about My Pet Carnivore?
Log in to ask your My Pet Carnivore question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
